Thursday, February 12, 2015

Errors - Whose Responsibility Are They?

An interesting question regarding how to judge a book when it's full of errors was posed this morning on an author board I'm a member of. You see, many members of this group, including me, are judges in a huge annual writing contest, and one of the things we're up against is who should take the blame for typos, spelling errors, and punctuation errors. Should we dock the author and reduce the score, or do we look the other way under the premise that it's the editor's fault, not the author's?

I bet U Turn is getting tired of hearing "no."

To Dock Or Not To Dock?

To answer this question, I think we need to look at the types of errors being made, as well as the volume.

First of all, we all make errors. I've never read a book that didn't have at least one error in it. Most have several. But as long as there aren't too many mistakes, and the reading experience isn't severely impacted, it's easy to look the other way.

Is this message only for the guardians of parents? And what are "ate's?" And time's what? This poster is a hot mess.

Where we run into a problem is when there are errors on every page. And not just errors, but glaring errors. Errors that make your skin crawl because they're so absurd that even a bad editor should have caught them. Errors that muddle the message and confuse the reader as to what is actually being said.

Yeah, those errors need to be docked. There's no excuse for them, and they've impeded the reading experience so severely, you have no choice but to deduct points. 

Additionally, I recently read a book that contained a ton of errors, but what was weird about them was that the author made those errors half the time, but wrote them correctly the other half. For example, she punctuated dialog tags correctly with the comma half the time. The other half she punctuated the dialog tag incorrectly with a period. Maybe an example would help:

Correct: "I want to go home," she said.
Incorrect: "I want to go home." she said.

She did this throughout the entire book. And she made this same kind of half-right-half-wrong error with other punctuation, spelling, etc. I was like, "She knows how to write it correctly, so why is she writing it incorrectly half the time?"

I had to dock points for that.

Who Do Errors Reflect On?

Let's look at a few examples:

"We are committed to 'excellense'"? Apparently, you're not.

"Were" opening...? I guess you're not now, huh?

If you're going to preach about our "lanaguage" to those who don't speak it, maybe you should learn it first. 
Like it or not, errors reflect on the person or business who made them public. The business who is committed to "excellense" just showed they're not that excellent. Dunkin Donuts' sign reflects on the business, not the person who printed the sign. And, yeah, the patriot in the minivan just shot him- or herself in the foot. 

In other words, in each of the above cases, not only was the message diminished by the errors, but they reflected on the person or public entity who represents them.

In the book world, that person is the author.

Who is Responsible for the Errors?

Like it or not, when it comes to errors in books, the author is ultimately held responsible. Not the editor, not the publisher, not the proofreader. The AUTHOR.

Think about it. When you're reading a book that's full of typos, do you say, "Ugh! That editor needs to learn how to edit," or "Ugh! This author needs to learn how to write."?

Maybe you're the one in a hundred that honestly blames the editor, but I've seen enough readers complain to know that 99% of the time, the author is blamed for typos, punctuation errors, misspelled words, and even bad formatting (which is WAY outside most authors' realm of responsibility, by the way). These readers aren't blaming the editor or proofreader. They're blaming the AUTHOR.

Don't dig your own grave with bad editing.

I once published a story with a small press. The publisher edited it in-house, but they never ran their edits by me for approval. When the story was published, I found that they had completely changed entire sentences, punctuation, and even the spelling of certain words, and in doing so, they created a lot of errors in my manuscript. Also, the book was for an American audience, but they formatted to British standards (colour instead of color, flavour instead of flavor, etc.). If you're writing for an American audience, you need to edit by American standards.

At any rate, I was furious. Luckily for me, I am extremely well-versed on punctuation and spelling. I edit as well as I write (with one exception: compound words. They are my nemesis). So, when I send my manuscripts to my editor now, it's really more about getting a second set of eyes on my story, so she can find the mistakes my author's eyes glossed over. And she's awesome sauce with compound words, so whew! Thank goodness for that. But my point is, I know an error when I see one.

So, back to this inept editor who marked up my manuscript with errors. Her mistakes reflected on ME. My name was on the book, not hers. As such, I was the one who stood to lose readers, not her. Because let's face it, there are a lot of savvy, educated readers out there who will ditch an author for a lot of things, including typos. That is the reality, like it or not. You can bitch and scream and try to "educate" those readers about whose fault those mistakes are, but it won't work. Those readers will still blame the author. It's a fact of publishing life we authors have to accept and strive to minimize in any way possible.

For me, the way I minimized the problem was  by never publishing with that publisher again. If this was the care they were going to give me, then thanks but no thanks. My reputation as an author is too important to me to let them foul it all up. And if they were going to be the cause of me losing readers, they needed to be cut loose. Ba-bye! I need a team around me that understands that this is MY work, MY reputation, and MY livelihood they're influencing. Those who take care of me, I will take care of in return. Those who don't...I wish you well, but see ya.

And therein lies the crux of this post. Authors need to take greater responsibility for their work, as well as greater control of the editing process, even when they're with a publisher. After all, it's the author's name on the book cover. As such, it's the author who has the most to lose from bad editing. Take the time to read those edits and not just trust that they're right. And if your publisher publishes your work without getting your approval on edits, it's time to find a new publisher.

Going back to the initial question then, how do you judge books with errors? My thoughts are, if a book is full of errors, no matter whose fault they are, judges should judge accordingly and deduct points if those errors are prolific and negatively impact the story and/or reading experience. Because, like I said, ultimately it's the author who's responsible for their own work.

Agree? Disagree? Feel free to weigh in in the comments.

Happy Writing!



  1. Hi Donya, I agree with you. Errors reflect on the author because hers is the identifiable brand. Not every reader can identify a publisher. As well as being a reader and an aspiring writer, I also work in the publishing industry, which means I am always interested in who the publisher is. However, even for me, a bad reading experience reflects on the author. It puts me off reading another one of her books, but in 95% of cases, it would not lead to me avoiding a publisher's entire list. Thanks for a very interesting post.

    1. You're welcome, and thank you for stopping by to comment. :) Good point about being put off by the author, but not by the publisher, by the way.

  2. Admittedly, you're right that it is unprofessional. However, if this is a judging of submitted, UNpublished books, I would consider NOT docking for the errors, as many authors are terrible spellers, typists, etc., but their thoughts are brilliant. For that reason, I think I would try to judge on content, only because you might miss out on an incredible body of work simply because their head was going quicker than their hands would allow them to. THAT SAID, if it was already written on the requirements for submitting their contents, then by all means, definitely dock. Then let them know why! This will prevent future stupidity on their part, hopefully.

  3. That's a very helpful list for students requiring help in starting their assignments, or for those trying to juggle multiple projects. Also check out if you have a finished assignment that you would like edited to make sure there are no typos or grammatical and syntactical errors. Their expert editors clean your copy and fintune it according to a particular citation style if required. They also give you great advice to rearrange your work to get the best results.

    Academic Editing and Proofreading Services
    Academic Editing Services
    Academic Proofreading Services
    Article Editing Services
    Article Writing Services
    Journal Article Editing Services
    Book Editing Services

  4. I agree that a second pair of eyes is absolutely essential to avoid rejections. Through I was able to get top class editing and proofreading, manuscript critique. They also write excellent author profiles and book synopsis, so pretty much the entire package.

    Proofreading Services For Business
    Research Paper Writing Services
    Children's Book Editing Services
    Children's Book Writing Services
    Scientific Editing Services
    Business Reports Editing
    Technical Editing Services
    Editing Services For Business

  5. Nice P ost...
    Avail Efficient HP Printer Troubleshooting Support From Tech-savvy
    In this fast paced world, time is more valuable than anything else. We always try to utilize our precious time in completing any productive task. Though, it is well-known to everybody that computer is completely inefficient when we do not use any of its hardware peripheral devices like printers, mouse, keyboards, flash drives, hard disks and many other beneficial devices. Like other devices, HP Printers are also an essential for the office and home premises. But we can’t deny the fact as well that printer may trouble sometime during printing due to unknown tech glitches. In order to instantly deal with the problem, getting the valuable HP Printer Troubleshooting tips and tricks is really fruitful to lower the stress and quick-fixing the printer error. Contacting highly-expert tech-geeks will be your one-stop solution to solve any complicated printer problem. Thus, place a call at 24/7 helpline number and stay tuned.

  6. I am working as a SMM panel. Here, you will easily get the point that owning an Cheapest SMM panel and provide SMM service is a legal thing, which means it is not a crime. It is very secure on our platform as well as they are resistant to DDoS-attack. Along with this, it also keeps updated from time to time to boost services.

  7. Wow, what an article. Please post some related articles as well. I am also here to promote my Garmin Express webpage. If you think you need to update or set up Garmin in your device then click our Garmin express update query for troubleshooting. By the way, Garmin is an application that is used to manage Garmin devices.
    Is your Garmin Express Not Working? Click the webpage for instant customer service.
    Thank You

  8. Superb blog and really great topic you choose. Helping students in writing an assignment is a good idea. We also offer cheap assignment help to students who are working part time and could not complete their assignment on time. We assign the subject specialist to each student who will write the assignment content and deliver it before the deadline arrives. Rest assured the content is always unique and plagiarism free. The process to raise a request is simple. Visit the website and drop the query and our team will connect with you. We provide the best services in the market at affordable rates. So, every student can get our Assignment writing services online.

  9. Roadrunner email login may be your task to obtain access to this webmail supplied by & for its users. Roadrunner email is among the most significant online customer base in the United States of America. Roadrunner mail provides its email services in a user-friendly interface, and an individual may receive the most useful features in their email address.
    But if somebody is confronting the Roadrunner email problems, can phone us to get assistance on your roadrunner email settings setup and troubleshooting.

  10. Thanks for sharing this article. It is really helpful for readers who are looking for online assignment help. I also work in the same area and provide assignment help to students for various subjects. Most of my students are from parts of the UK, USA, India, and Singapore. Our team of professors are from reputed Colleges. Visit our website to know our areas of expertise and let us know if we can be of help.

  11. Looking for professionals for Economics assignment help? Then don’t worry! We provide academic writing services for 100+ subjects that are high in quality. Connect with our highly qualified professionals now.

  12. it is in reality a correctly-researched content material and high-quality wording.
    I got correspondingly engaged in this fabric that I couldnt wait analyzing. i am impressed in the end your positioned it on and skillability. thank you

    amazon quiz
    gk quiz
    quiz games
    english stories
    bedtime stories
    short stories
    short bedtime stories
    english stories collection

  13. Readers are always admiring informational blogs, and this is truly one of them. You did a great job. If you want to enhance writing skills, based assignment writer is the best solution for you. Dissertation writing Service Sharjah

  14. This article is superb very creative superior work i enjoyed it.Learn more about devops course here explore more about our courses

  15. You can tell when your projects make a difference from the crowd. There's something unique about the projects. It appears to me that they are all amazing! the smm panel

  16. Thank you so much for sharing this great blog.Very inspiring and helpful too. You can also go through my latest article History of morse this might be a great help to you.

  17. This comment has been removed by the author.

  18. Great post keep writing .Want to take assignment help online we are here to give you all kind of writing services at a one place further more information then let me know. Writing services are very valuable for all student who pursuing in colleges or schools too. You can contact us via website or social media platform.

  19. Round-the-clock Assignment Help is available to students who are seeking instant paper solutions. We have Ph.D. scholars in every academic field and every one of them is highly experienced in writing assignment papers. Students can sort out every paper query and secure high-quality grades with customize answers.

  20. Nos proporcionaste algunos hechos sorprendentes en esta maravillosa publicación. Aprecio que lo hagas. Este perfil me fue útil clicks por segundo. Estaría feliz de compartir este perfil, que tiene alrededor de clics por segundo, contigo. Puede controlar su tasa de CPS y su tasa de clics. El chasquido debe continuar hasta que tus brazos se rindan.

  21. very informative and impressive article. Thanks for sharing with us
    cyfuture cloud